Skip to main content

Table 9 Discriminative criteria used in Nebularmis taxonomy (all traits refer to states present in adults if not referred directly to other life stages; comparison based on all examined populations, see also [78, 28] for N. cirinoi and N reticulatus)

From: New Indomalayan Nebularmis species (Heterotardigrada: Echiniscidae) provoke a discussion on its intrageneric diversity

CHARACTERISTIC

Nebularmis auratus sp. nov.

Nebularmis bhutanensis sp. nov.

Nebularmis burmensis sp. nov.

Nebularmis cirinoi

Nebularmis crebraclava

Nebularmis indicus sp. nov.

Nebularmis reticulatus

Cephalic papilla

elongated and thin

very large and swollen

elongated and thin

elongated and thin

elongated and thin

elongated and thin

elongated and thin

Primary clava

elongated, reduced

blunt-ended, of average size

elongated, reduced

blunt-ended, of average size

blunt-ended, of average size

elongated, reduced

usually blunt-ended, of average size

Cirrus A

1722% of the body length, with smooth and thickened proximal end of flagellum

2226% of the body length, with smooth and slightly thickened proximal end of flagellum

1619% of the body length, with smooth proximal end of flagellum roughly equal in width to the distal end

2835% of the body length, with smooth and slightly thickened proximal end of flagellum

1627% of the body length, with smooth and slightly thickened proximal end of flagellum

1926% of the body length, with smooth and thickened proximal end of flagellum

2763% of the body length, often with rugose proximal end of flagellum roughly equal in width to the distal end

Micropores in the scapular plate

present and randomly distributed (absent in juveniles)

present along anterior and posterior margins

absent

absent

absent

absent

absent or present along anterior and posterior margins (present in juveniles)

Epicuticular granules

tendency towards merging, but still well-separated in some plates

well-separated in all plates, hexagonal and not circular, with evident striae

well-separated in median and anterior portions of paired segmental plates, evident bumps in the latter

strong tendency towards merging, circular and very wide

well-separated in all plates, with very wide spaces between them, hexagonal and not circular, with evident striae

well-connected by thick striae but clearly separated in all plate portions except for the lateralmost portions of paired segmental plates

strong tendency towards merging, usually visible in the scapular plate

Pedal plate IV

unsculptured

strongly sculptured

unsculptured

weakly sculptured

strongly sculptured

unsculptured

unsculptured

Claw branches IV [μm/sp]

19.222.2

31.6–33.6

17.320.1

34.4–44.9

18.120.5

32.9–37.1

15.219.7

26.6–33.7

16.121.4b

15.618.0

30.7–40.7

17.533.9

29.9–49.4

Claw spurs

of average size, isonych and with blunt ends

very large and heteronych, spurs IV larger and more divergent from branches than spurs IIII

small and short, isonych

of average size and heteronych, spurs IV larger and more divergent from branches than spurs IIII

very large, no data available on whether spurs IV differ from spurs I–III

small and short, isonych

large and isonych

Malesa

unknown

present

unknown

absent

present

present

absent

  1. a Numerous populations of N. cirinoi and N reticulatus have been examined, and no males were found; thus, the assertion about their parthenogenetic nature is supported. For two other species, Nebularmis auratus sp. nov. and Nebularmis burmensis sp. nov., population sizes were too small to exclude dioecy
  2. b Data not provided in the original description [66]
  3. Proximal end of flagellum = flagellum base